"Reputation" Poll

Should we keep the Reputation System?

  • Yes, I find it very useful

    Votes: 20 25.0%
  • No, I don't think we really need it

    Votes: 48 60.0%
  • Keep it, but turn off the negative feedback.

    Votes: 12 15.0%

  • Total voters
    80
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it like All-Star voting, you each voted 25 times for each other? Cause that's what it looks like

What do you mean? The admins/mods are on the same level as everyone else.

Maybe because we've been members since 2006?

Hard to say. Many factors come into play. Want me to post the factors here?

Everyone is taking this way too seriously. It means nothing. It's like playing Nintendo or something, where you get "power' for doing something. That's what it reminds me of.
 
I've been following this thread and doing math.

looks like there are about 3 no's generated for each yes vote, well actually 3.875. I think the .875 are the actual legitimate votes.

file.php
 
Carol,

This gives you an idea of the in-fighting/jealousy that can go on.......I quit Dodge Forum for almost a half year until things finally got back to normal. I got tired of acting like a PI trying to figure out who sent the nasty PM/email to whom. Some of my best friends never returned, though....I'd hate to have that happen here!!!

Dusty
 
Carol,

This gives you an idea of the in-fighting/jealousy that can go on.......I quit Dodge Forum for almost a half year until things finally got back to normal. I got tired of acting like a PI trying to figure out who sent the nasty PM/email to whom. Some of my best friends never returned, though....I'd hate to have that happen here!!!

Dusty

Actually admins can read private messages in the privatmessage table in phpmyadmin.
 
There is already a problem with this. Mostly everyone responding here has a rep in the single digits, except the owners and mods, who have roughly 50 to 60 points. What's up with that? Is it like All-Star voting, you each voted 25 times for each other? Cause that's what it looks like.


You got us all figured out...
 
Actually admins can read private messages in the privatmessage table in phpmyadmin.

Huh? Nobody has access to our server except Vlad, and why would he want to read PM's? he has better things to do believe me. :roll:
 
No he's not, he's just trying to hide behind my Rep Power rating of 38, no wait!!!! Now it's 39!!!!!

Can I change my vote????????

(Just messin with ya, Detecto!!! Nice picture of ya, BTW!!) Gotcha again!!! BTW thanks for the speedy shipping on the silver!!!:yes::yes::D:D

Dusty
 
You got us all figured out...

Craig, it was a straight question. If you had a slightly higher number, no problem, but your numbers are out of line with even the elite members. If your numbers were part of a scientific study, they'd be discarded as being too far from the mean.

There is another problem with the mods/owners/admins having high "Trust" numbers. You all have a financial interest in this forum. Correct? Or at least some of you do. So a newbie comes along wanting the straight info on a detector purchase, reads the high rep number and thinks this guy is trustworthy. Yet, really, it's this guy is paid. Not that any of you would purposely mislead anyone, the point is, you can't trust someone with a financial interest in the outcome for purchase advice. Your sponsors pay good money for that outcome to be positive. And, that fact of life influences your advice.

The rep number, as it relates to those with a financial interest in this site, creates an ethical dilemma. You can't be straight with people looking for advice, because that advice could be in conflict with your need to protect your clients. Maybe mods/admin/owners should be exempt from the system?
 
Well, we can't here Detecto...

Thats nice, why when you delete a comment in your profile section they just say deleted. I thought I was cleaning up old comments when I realized that comment section was for greetings and such.

What can pimpmyadmin do about that :lol:



hey! can a geta leg up here? TOAST? Detecto?... nothing? I don't cheat anybody
imagesCA2ZT3C7.jpg
I swear

I got a good credit score... does that count.... come on! 4 really?
how about most post deleted... that has to be worth something, can we get a 5, do I hear 5, 5? anyone?
 
Craig, it was a straight question. If you had a slightly higher number, no problem, but your numbers are out of line with even the elite members. If your numbers were part of a scientific study, they'd be discarded as being too far from the mean.

There is another problem with the mods/owners/admins having high "Trust" numbers. You all have a financial interest in this forum. Correct? Or at least some of you do. So a newbie comes along wanting the straight info on a detector purchase, reads the high rep number and thinks this guy is trustworthy. Yet, really, it's this guy is paid. Not that any of you would purposely mislead anyone, the point is, you can't trust someone with a financial interest in the outcome for purchase advice. Your sponsors pay good money for that outcome to be positive. And, that fact of life influences your advice.

The rep number, as it relates to those with a financial interest in this site, creates an ethical dilemma. You can't be straight with people looking for advice, because that advice could be in conflict with your need to protect your clients. Maybe mods/admin/owners should be exempt from the system?

If you had access to my user CP you would see who gave me the rep points and they were not mods...

When I or anyone else puts up a good or helpful post and people like it they say so with a positive rep... its as simple as that..

actually on my user CP it says I have 78 reps but 63 are posted...


You all have a financial interest in this forum. Correct? Or at least some of you do.


Where do you come up with this stuff?

None of us get anything... we do it because we love this forum... we are here to help members and keep this forum drama free to the best of our ability...
 
Here's "some" of the factors I gleaned from the vbulletin community forum.

Whenever someone rates a post either x reputations points is subtracted or added to the reputation total. That x is called reputation altering power. So when a 2 year old member rates someone it has more influence then a new user rating the same post.

----------------------------------

Say you start with 1 point.
When you alter the reputation of someone else, you will give +1 or -1.

Say you won an altering point.
When you alter the reputation of someone else, you will give +2 or -2.

-----------------------------------------------

Everyone starts out with 10 points as does a new person registering. But many people had several hundred or more posts and some have been around for a while. So - they get a number which they can see in their profile. The number in the profile is the Reputation level (as opposed to their Reputation Altering number).

------------------------------------------------

Reputation Point Factor
For every X points of reputation, users gain 1 point of reputation-altering power.

So - if a user has 300 'points' in their 'reputation' (the number that shows in their profile) they have a second number which is their 'reputation altering' power (and this is different from their 'reputation' points).

---------------------------------------

- Everyone has a reputation = total of reputation : it is your points of reputation, and it starts at 10.

- Everyone has a reputation power = altering power : it is how much you can affect other's reputation (adding or subtracting), and it starts at 0 or 1, and can only grow with register date, post count and reputation.

--------------------------------------------------

First the easy one, putting 0 for any of the factors, will effectively disable that factor from having any effect on reputation power (how much a user gives and takes). Also, giving negative reputation only takes 1/2 of what positive would give, the value you see listed when you edit a user in the admin cp.

As for the dots, there is no chart for this since normally a user isn't supposed to actually know what a series of dots translates to in numeric terms. Just that bright green dots are better than dark green dots and the more dots you have, the higher the reputation. Having any bright dots at all means you have a higher reputation than someone who only has dark green dots. Same thing with the red dots, just in reverse.

The maximum number of dots you will see is 11 (in the current system).

Reputation

-99 to 0
0 to 99
100 to 199
200 to 299
300 to 399
400 to 499

Once you hit 500, you will start gaining bright green dots on top of the 5 dark dots but it takes twice as much to gain a bright green dot.

500 to 699
700 to 899
900 to 1099
1100 to 1299
1300 to 1499
1500 and up

Negative values work pretty much the same way except it shows balanced (grey dot) from -99 to 0. I've just changed the code to only show balanced if your reputation is 0, less than 0 and it will show red dots. Some other things that I will be adding will be for you to be able to alter how often the dots show up so you can better adjust the system if you expect to have high or low reputation values.

Hope this helps. I've had to do alot of studying. Actually, I have "Reputation Burnout." :lol:

But, since we're probably going to turn this feature off, maybe we can do something different. like... Custom User Titles. :shock:
 
If you had access to my user CP you would see who gave me the rep points and they were not mods...

When I or anyone else puts up a good or helpful post and people like it they say so with a positive rep... its as simple as that..

actually on my user CP it says I have 78 reps but 63 are posted...

That doesn't explain why it's so much higher than other LT members.
 
Thats nice, why when you delete a comment in your profile section they just say deleted. I thought I was cleaning up old comments when I realized that comment section was for greetings and such.

What can pimpmyadmin do about that :lol:



hey! can a geta leg up here? TOAST? Detecto?... nothing? I don't cheat anybody
imagesCA2ZT3C7.jpg
I swear

I got a good credit score... does that count.... come on! 4 really?

Not sure what your issue is, but Visitor Messages in your Public Profile are just that PUBLIC. Private Messages are also what they say...PRIVATE!!
 
Have not read all the post but I voted no.I don't think anything was wrong before this so,what is the purpose of rating everyone? After you have read post for a little while you know what member's post have credibility.Just my 2 cents.Thanks for the Great Foruum.Ken
 
I haven't voted one way or the other. The new rep system wouldn't affect how or why i use this forum anyhow. I came here because its the best looking and friendliest forum ive seen where everyone is just laid back (most of the time) and can share thier finds of the day with everyone. I don't quite yet understand it yet though, why some people have 100 posts and 2 green dots and others have 1 green dot and 2,000+ posts or how you get more rep...by every 200 or so posts it goes up im assuming. But on the other hand that can be a bit pointless also because from what i've seen most people that have 2,000+ posts are the ones who just go right down the list of all the new member sign ups and say "welcome" 100 times and then go to the finds section and post "nice find" on every new post...so getting rep up that way would be easy with all the 1 and 2 word posts that really aren't helpful in any way. I still think its a pretty neat idea though, atleast they're trying to do something new around the forum. It's pretty ungrateful of the people i see bashing Carol and the admins for trying something new around here, they dont HAVE to keep this site up for all of us at all ya know. :roll:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom