First of all I would like to say nice job on the silver and the wheat penny. It's always exciting to find a new oldest coins. Keep up the good work and you will find plenty more.
If you are calling the round object with the star in the center a kid's toy badge I'm not sure that's what it is. I think it is a love token or a good luck token that used to be quite popular at truck stops and gas stations. Back in the early 80s my girlfriend who is now my wife printed one up for me while she was out of town.
That kids toy badge, actually looks like a good luck token, that people could make at a fair with their own messages on them. If the person who made it was a smart arse, it may be interesting to read lol.