anyone using the 12.5" or 5" coils of this brand? i have the 8" inch minelab but am wondering how these compare to the sunray brand of products?
I have a lot to say and only a few minutes. I hope I can get it all in and not screw up too much here.
I for years believed that if you wanted the very best in coils you needed to buy the manufacture’s accessory coils. My friend who I do a lot of metal detecting with purchased the White’s D2 10” DD coil for use on his V3, DFX and MXT detectors and we were all blown away by the performance of this wonderful new coil from White’s. And after using the coil myself on my MXT I just had to have one!
So, I decided it would be my next accessory coil. However, I was going to be leaving for a two week trip to hunt some old CCC Camps in here in New Jersey and I wanted the coil for that trip and my wife could not get the White’s D2, there were out of stock at both local White’s dealers.
Then my wife thought of calling Kellyco where I had bought my first MXT and later my M-6 detector. However, kind employee at Kellyco told my wife that they did not have the D2 in stock but did have a few EXcelerator 10” DD coils in stock and that it was a very good coil. So she order one for me and told me that if I was not happy with it, she would get me the R2 when it was available and keep the EXcelerator. And to be honest I was a little disappointed that I didn’t get the R2.
After getting the EXcelerator I went out with my buddy and we set up a test bed with nickels, silver dimes, silver quarters and Eisenhower Dollars buried at depths of 6, 8, 10 and 12 inches as well as a Morgan Dollar buried at 14 inches.
The Excelerator 10” DD and the White’s R2 10” DD both hit the nickels, silver quarters and Eisenhower Dollars at all depths. However, when it came to the silver dimes, the R2 on both my MXT and my friend’s MXT missed the silver at 10 inches. So we tried 9 inches and the R2 then was able to hit the silver dime on both machines with a very faint signal/low whisper.
The EXcelerator 10” DD on both MXT machines was able to get a good lock on the silver dime at 10 inches. So we then tried the silver dime at 11 inches and on both MXT’s with the EXcelerator 10” DD was able to hit the silver dime consistently!
If you view my album of Silver Coins I recovered on my CCC Camp hunt you will see that most of the 28 Silver Coins that I recovered were found with the EXcelerator 10” DD. When viewing the picture of the coin take the time to read the details of my recover I posted on each of the photos and see the depth that some of these coins were recovered.
In short the EXcelerator 10” DD and White’s R2 10” DD are pretty much dead even in performance. However the EXcelerator actually is more sensitive on the smaller silver coins and able to hit them better and at great depth then the R2 was capable of doing. EXcelerator is slightly heavier but also more sturdy then the White’s coil. We have had two R2 Coils go bad, but have had no problems with the EXcelerator Coils.
I’ve also use the 10x12” DD SEF (Butterfly) and it is a top performer as well.
After my CCC Camp Hunt and my recent Civil War Relic Hunt in Virginia, I know that Kellyco has sold at least 5 of these coils (the EXcelerator 10" DD) in recent weeks after people have seen mine in action and have tried it for themselves. But unfortunately my experience is limited to these two Excelerator Coils, but others I hear from that use different Excelerator Coils are very pleased with their coils.
Oh, by the way, I no longer need the R2. It is a very good coil, I just like the EXcelerator a little more.
Both coils hit the Morgan Dollar at 14 inches.
Best Regards,
Silver Hawk