Yes, the method "works", but it has serious limitations. More importantly, we have no evidence that it actually works any better than the other methods we already use to find rings...and that's a pretty damn important thing to know!
In addition, the method doesn't reliably distinguish pull tabs from rings, and pull tabs are one of the biggest hindrances to finding rings in parks. Then of course, there are all the false negatives of the method to consider.
Posting that someone found a ring using the method is not proof that the method is effective, because there's no way of knowing whether that same ring would have been found using conventional methods. Finding a ring while using a particular method doesn't establish that the method was responsible for finding it. There's also the question of how many rings or other jewelery (becuase the method only works on closed loop) are passed over because they didn't produce the desired ID change.
Even if the method reduces the amount of trash being dug, that doesn't necessarily mean it results in finding more rings. It could simply mean fewer holes being dug, while potentially passing over rings and jewelry that don't produce the wanted ID change.
In addition, it could even be found that digging only mid conductors while notching out pull tabs could produce more gold rings than using this method. We simply don't know, because no proper comparison has been done.
A proper test would involve checking a large number of unknown targets with the method, at avarious depths and orientations, recording which ones pass and fail the frequency test, and then digging every single target, including those the method says to reject. That would establish the percentage of gold rings and gold jewelry the method correctly identifies, the percentage it misses, and how much trash it actually eliminates. The results would also need to be compared with conventional ring finding methods.
Until someone does a proper comparison with conventional methods, I don't see how anyone can claim this method is more effective at finding rings. It might be, but it might also be less effective. Right now, I don't think we have the proper evidence to say one way or the other.