$72,500 1943-S wheat back penny
Get your magnets out and check those steel wheat backs!
Previously Unaccounted 1943-S Bronze Cent Acquired by Rare Coin Wholesalers
(Dana Point, California) — A previously unrecorded 1943-S Lincoln cent, erroneously struck on a bronze planchet and found in circulation by a teenaged collector over a half century ago, has been acquired by Rare Coin Wholesalers of Dana Point, California.
The discovery coin now is certified as AU-53 by Numismatic Guaranty Corporation.
"The coin was found in 1944 by Kenneth S. Wing Jr. of Long Beach, California who was assembling a set of Lincoln cents at the time," said Steven L. Contursi, President of Rare Coin Wholesalers (www.RCW1.com).
Wing became a prominent Southern California architect who co-designed the Long Beach Arena in the late 1950s. He passed away in 1996.
"When his heirs recently asked me to examine the coin, I doubted it was genuine. But then I got a magnet and was surprised when the coin did not stick to it. So, on behalf of Mr. Wing’s heirs I submitted it for certification," Contursi explained.
"It’s delightful and amazing there are still examples of great numismatic rarities to be ‘discovered’ and reported to the hobby."
Contursi plans to publicly display the 1943-S bronze cent at various coin shows including the upcoming American Numismatic Association World’s Fair of Money® in Baltimore and the Long Beach Coin, Stamp & Collectibles Expo in September.
To honor the memory of the coin’s finder and the family that owned it for 64 years, he requested that NGC include the notation on the encapsulation insert label, "Kenneth S. Wing Jr. Coll."
"My Father was an avid penny collector. His parents would get him rolls of pennies from the bank every few weeks, and he’d search through them. He found the 1943 (bronze) penny in Long Beach in 1944 when he was 14 years old, but I’m not sure if it was from pocket change or from a roll (of circulating cents) from the bank. He took it to a local dealer who offered him $500 for it, but my Father said it wasn’t for sale."
The coin was in a simple Capitol Plastics cent holder in a bank safe deposit box with the rest of Wing’s collection, found there after he died in 1996. Paul Wing says his father didn’t talk much about the coin over the years, and he didn’t actually see it until after his father passed away.
"My Father pulled most of his collection from circulation, and purchased a few coins he could not find. He found a 1922 ‘no D’ cent in change, but had to eventually buy a 1909-S V.D.B.," explained the son.
Those coins remain in the collection inherited by Wing’s family.
"The 1943 bronze Lincoln cent really transcends a wrong planchet error. Today, it’s widely considered to be a classic twentieth century rarity, more kin to a transitional type, and now is collected as part of the regular series by devoted Lincoln cent enthusiasts," commented Dave Camire, President of Numismatic Conservation Services and a mint error consultant to NGC.
"This piece is particularly important because it’s from San Francisco, a scarcer mint for the issue compared to better-known Philadelphia Mint specimens. This coin is also a recent discovery to the numismatic community," Camire stated.
Common zinc-coated steel cents will stick to a magnet but the handful of known 1943-dated Lincoln cents mistakenly struck in bronze (in this case, an alloy of 95 percent copper and 5 percent tin and zinc) will not. The zinc-coated steel metallic composition was used in 1943 to conserve copper that was needed for U.S. efforts in World War II.
"When I purchased the coin I also received Mr. Wing’s interesting file of correspondence dating back to 1946 as he tried to verify the coin’s authenticity. Some of the responses he received from the Mint, the Smithsonian Institution and well-known dealer of the era, Abe Kosoff, may seem a little humorous today."
In a letter to Wing dated August 20, 1946, Acting Director of the Mint Leland Howard wrote:
"In reference to your letter of August 11th, there were no copper cents struck during the calendar year 1943 at any of the coinage Mints. Only the zinc coated steel cent was struck during that year."
Today, though, the hobby is aware of more than a dozen 1943 bronze cents with at least one example known from each of the Mints producing Lincoln cents that year: Philadelphia, Denver and San Francisco.
Contursi acquired the coin and correspondence for $72,500. The letters from and to Wing indicate he tried for decades to get information about his historic, off-metal cent.
Wing wrote to Encino, California dealer Kosoff on October 3, 1958:
"In 1948, on a trip to San Francisco, it (the coin) was shown to the Director of the mint and his ‘private’ opinion was that of authenticity. In 1957, my Father was in Washington, DC, (sic) he attempted to have the Treasury Department examine it, however, they refused and referred him to the Smithsonian Institution."
In his response dated October 8, 1958, Kosoff replied:
"It would be of prime importance to determine, beyond any doubt, that your 1943-S Cent is a genuine one. This would require a number of tests and the outlay of considerable cash."
Additional correspondence regarding the coin’s journey to Washington with Wing’s father is a June 18, 1957 letter from V. Clain-Stefanelli, Curator of the Division of Numismatics at the Smithsonian in which he wrote:
"The authenticity of this piece is in my opinion beyond doubt. In fact, as you certainly recall, Mr. Mendel L. Peterson, Acting Head Curator of the Department of History, fully concurred in this opinion."
Contursi said his recently-acquired 1943 bronze Lincoln cent is quite special for him.
"Of all the million dollar coins I’ve bought or sold – from Brasher Doubloons to the King of Siam set – this is the first 1943 ‘copper penny’ I’ve ever owned!"
Fisher F75 LTD2 w/ Sun Ray Invader FX-1 - Fisher CZ-5 w/ Sun Ray Invader FZ-1 - Garrett Grand Master Hunter CXII - White's Surfmaster