I bought a used Ace 250 from a forum member and found the stock coil "irritating" for lack of better words, compared to my At Pro. I purchased the 8.5x11 DD coil for it and it seemed like a new, completely different machine.
It definitely separates better and there are far fewer false signals. It also recovers faster with less one way signals. I can do the "wiggle" for pinpointing just as I do with the AT Pro. I can't say anything about depth because the stock coil wasn't on it long enough to determine that. Your experiences may differ but this is what I've found.
As for the 5x8 coil, I personally keep the 8.5x11 on my AT Pro 90% of the time. I use the 5x8 when I feel the need to like in the water, tall grass, or when there are a lot of ferns in the woods. It is lighter, but I'm 48 years old with a shoulder surgery and a shattered collar bone from a motorcycle accident (3 years ago) and I hunt until I'm done hunting, not because I'm too tired to swing it. If I had to sell one of my coils it would be the 5x8 just for the fact that I don't use it as much.
The Ace 250 get used mostly buy an older friend of mine who is slightly disabled, and we will spend between 5, and up to 8 hours hunting with the larger coils with no ill effects from swinging them. My wife uses it also.
So my opinion would be to buy the 8.5x11 coil for the ACE 250 and you'll be happy you did.
Jeff