My experience md'ing a military base (long)

Tom_in_CA

Elite Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2013
Messages
20,746
Part I

In 1994, my wife heard from some friends, that the back-country of Ft. Ord (then an active base) was a good place to run dogs off-leash. Miles of hiking trails, dogs-off-leash ok, public allowed, etc... So we decided to take our dog out there and go for a hike. And I decided to combine it and do some metal detecting too at old abandoned PT fields I knew of back there :)

We arrived at the gate. As we passed through check-point charlie, they were passing a paper to all cars. It showed closed roads. Since some back-country roads were only open to authorized vehicles only (or whatever). I looked over the map, and deduced that the area I wanted to go to, was on roads that weren't closed. So far, so good :)

We drove back to the part of the base that our friends had told us had the hiking trails, and where I knew some WWII and cold-war era PT exercise areas had been. I pulled off to the side of the road to a chip gravel shoulder frontage. My wife let the dog out and started walking around. I went to the rear of my truck to get my detecting gear out.

I'm putting on my apron, checking my batteries, getting my digger out, etc.... We had been there no longer than 60 seconds, when an MP vehicle approached at high speed. He screeched to a halt right behind my truck. The guy gets out of his truck and starts yelling at us: "What are you doing!?" I can't recall his exact words and questions, as this was nearly 20 yrs. ago. But he was obviously very upset about us, and had rapid fire questions. I recall he saw the digger I had in my hand, and he yells "drop your weapon!". Meanwhile, my wife who had walked a short distance away from the truck by this time, needless to say, had come back. Our dog, meanwhile, oblivious to what's going on, had gone towards the MP, wagging his tail, curious to greet the person. The MP started yelling at us to "control your animal!" We quickly got the dog in the truck. All the while the MP is on his radio calling for backups.

At this time, I seriously thought it had something to do with the metal detector. On the other hand, I knew he hadn't even seen that yet, when rolling up on us. So I was perplexed what our crime was. He was yelling "show me your ID and registration, what is your purpose for being in this spot" and so forth. I'm trying to answer his questions, of course. I remember he had walked to the rear of my truck, looked in the truck bed, and saw some spent shells. Just junk I'd pitched in the back bed after previous hunts elsewhere (along with pulltabs or whatever , since I hadn't been near a trash can). When the officer saw some bullet shells, he got unbent even more and was yelling: "what's this contraband ammunition ??!!" It was all surreal !

As he kept yelling and shouting commands, I began to sense the guy wasn't playing with a full-deck. Someone very bent on authority, power, etc... So I decided right then and there that this treatment was simply not right. I noticed he had a lapel pin badge on, with his name on it. I squinted to see the name, but he was standing too far away to see. So I asked him his name, but for some reason, he wouldn't give it to me. Changes the subject, shouting more commands and yelling. So I stepped forward squinting to see the badge name. And at this he pulls his gun, aims it at me, and says "never make a threatening move towards an officer!!". He orders us both into the cab of the truck, at gunpoint, and tells us to put our hands on the dash. At this point I REALLY knew the guy was a tinder-box!

My wife was now in tears , and we were both trembling with fear. He got our ID, registration, etc.... as his backups arrive. I distinctly recall seeing in my rear view mirror as the two conferred back at their vehicles behind us, the look at the back-up's face. It was one of which "you called me out here for THIS?" type look :?:. This was adding to my suspicion that this was all un-called for. The guy wouldn't even tell us what we had done wrong up to this point !

In the end, we found out that apparently one or more of our tires were off-the-pavement. The fine print at the bottom of the paper they pass out had something to the effect of "stay on paved roads". And perhaps where I parked didn't qualify as "paved". It was chip-gravel, and appeared to be paved, but ....was not the road-way per se, or dedicated lots to parking perhaps, or some such semantics like that. So therefore the a) dog off leash, b) metal detector, c) being on a base, etc... were all not issues that he'd stopped us for.

In the end, after 30 minutes of yelling, belittling us, etc... he said he was going to let us off the hook. But that we had to leave right now. He escorted our truck all the way back to the exit gates (as if I might turn around and plant a nuclear bomb ?). I was embarassed, and my wife was still in tears. I was especially mad that it made me look bad in front of my wife. Because she was trusting me to know where we're going, etc... Now I looked like an utter fool that brought all sorts of trouble on to us!

I made up my mind that I was going to complain to his superiors about this treatment. So the next morning, I went to the MP's main office. I told them I'd like to lodge a complaint against one of their officers. I was led down some hallways to a high-ranking officer who was nearing retirement age. His rank was "sergeant major". He invited me to tell him what my complaint was.

He agreed that it sounded like excessive use of force. And he said he could write the guy up for a formal charge/complaint. But that if he did that, that he would ALSO have to write me a ticket for having my car parked off the approved type asphalt or whatever thing the arriving MP had decided I'd done wrong.

For a brief moment, I weighed the option: Is it worth getting a $100 ticket JUST to see the guy get a reprimand or whatever? He told me he was sorry for his officer's attitude, but that if I wished to press charges, he'd have to give me a ticket too. I decided that I didn't want to pay a dime. So I told the sergeant major, "just forget it then".

As I got ready to leave, he stopped me and said he'd compromise. He said he'd put a notation in the MP's folder, but that it would only serve as notation purpose. I agreed.

Now at this point, you're probably all wondering "what does this have to do with metal detecting, since none of that was what I was stopped for?". Here's where metal detecting fits in:
 
part II

part II

While explaining to the sergeant major my complaint, he invariably asks "what were you doing in the rear of the base?". At that point, I was forthcoming that one of my intentions , was to "metal detect". He even asked about it, what was I looking for, etc... I explained it's a hobby, it finds coins, etc.... I didn't want to be less than forthcoming about every single detail of the encounter afterall. Since if this was going to lead to something formal, that might all come out anyhow.

But after all was said and done, and he said he would only put a notation in the guy's folder, I did the following: I switched the conversation back over to metal detecting. And asked: "it's ok to metal detect on base here, right? I mean, as long as it's not a closed area, or an area closed for munitions cleanup, etc... right? " I gave as example the old parade grounds, barracks lawns (which were just becoming abandoned at that point), etc.... He told me that casual metal detecting for coins and trinkets was ok. I distinctly remember the words "casual", because I wrote it down on the back of his business card.

No doubt the fellow was trying to be nice, because he was embarrassed at the behavior of his officer. So perhaps this senior guy was not thinking through my question with all the ramifications it could have (ie.: cultural heritage, holes, or whatever). I'll grant you this. But since I could tell from the tone of the conversation leading up to this, that detecting had nothing to do with it, I figured I'd get that part milked a little bit more :)

I took the fellow's card, with his quote pencilled in on the back, and carry it to this day in my wallet. That senior fellow is long gone now. In fact, I heard he passed away a year or two after that. But I still carry this card with me to this day. And .... on at least two occasions, when questioned, I have shown that and said "this guy said it was ok". Mind you that anyone I show it to NOW does not even know the guy. However, when they see the rank "sergeant major" on there, they will often just shy away. Doh! I mean, at best have said "well, he has no authority on this particular base" or something.
 
Part III

Part III

One day, in about 1999 or so, I got a phone call. Some military lawyer person calling me was asking me if I recalled being in an incident blah blah. I said "yes, I recall that incident". He asked me if I would be willing to testify in a court trial involving that officer.

As the story un-folded, I was made aware that this same officer (who'd pulled the gun on me) had been involved in an off-duty gun-waving incident in a bar, drinking with his buddies. He pulled his gun and start spouting off to the others in the bar, etc.... The police got called, and quelled the disturbance. That information got back to his MP superiors, and caused there to be a formal hearing. When they opened up his personell folder, to see his past work record, it turns out there were several OTHER "gun-waving" incidents as well, while on the job, ... INCLUDING MY NOTATION. So they tracked down my phone # and were now asking if would please come in as a witness in his court trial. And now, in proper military procedure, it had turned into a personell court case thing, and govt. was needing to show that this "gun-waving" was not isolated to just the one bar incident. Eg.: for the government's lawyers to show a "pattern of behavior" .

So I, and a few others testified in court as to our run-ins with the fellow. Including a 12 yr. old boy who he'd caught BMX bike riding on back country trails, and had the kid lie flat eagle on the dirt, handcuffed the kid, guns pointed, etc...!

In the end, the MP was demoted to a desk job, and can never carry a gun again.

So there's my story about getting caught with a metal detector on federal military land.
 
So in the end you still got to have your day with the guy! Props to you for handling it the way you did. Not sure if I would have been so calm when he pulled his gun. I would have been pissed and at the least had a superior on site after the back up guys got there.
 
Tom- In this case it sounds like you should have risked the $100.00 fine and took one for the hobby. Might have kept someone else from getting harassed.
 
Well? Did you ever find anything? :?: :lol:

ha, well, metal detecting at Ft. Ord in many years before this, and many years after this, has never been a big deal. One of the reasons it never occurred to me I needed to "ask" before bringing my detector on that hike, was that that others routinely detected there.

Like: if you get into the hobby and join a club (say for instance). And at the club's show & tell time, others show "found at such & such park" or "found at such & such beach". Then ... you ... as a newbie, just assume it must be ok to detect there. :?: It wouldn't even cross your mind as a question. Or like the analogy of coming to the pond in central park, and seeing toy RC boats on the pond. One assumes it must be legal (you'd probably never even muse the point).

So too was/is it for Ft. Ord: During the 1970s (when I was a kid) it was an open base at times, or during a few years, you signed in at the visitor center when coming on to base. We had 2 sizable clubs in this area, and a dealer since the very early 1970s, so there were already a lot of detectors around here by the late 1970s. And Ft. Ord was just one of the many places people detected. Of course, I'm sure they had the "presence of mind" to not go during the middle of drills, etc.. :roll:

And one of the reasons this might have just been "normal", was that since Ft. Ord was basically a city within itself, we always had a few enlisted military who were into the hobby themselves. So when they'd show up at the club meeting with all the goodies they were finding around barracks and such, then they simply invite their new found civilian friends to join them.

Thus for these reasons, it was never even wondered "is it legal?". This was in the days before the internet and FMDAC mailers flooded us with "scary stories", afterall, which NOW causes every new person to scurry down to "ask permission". I suppose, that even back in the 1970s, if enough of us civilians had gone to enough military brass asking "can I?", well sure, maybe "no" would have been forthcoming. But SO TOO can the same thing be said of ANY city or county park, school, etc.... If you ask enough questions, with the right combination of words, you can ALWAYS fetch a "no".
 
Great story Tom! Not getting into this hobby until after I retired I missed allot of the "Glory Years" of detecting around our area. :(:no: Never have made it over to the former Fort Ord. Got any stories about the Presidio/DLI or Naval Post Grad School?!? ;):D
 
... Got any stories about the Presidio/DLI or Naval Post Grad School?!? ;):D

Yup :)

Got silver from both of them. They have complicated long histories. At times have been "open base" policy, but at other times "closed base" policy. At present, go figure, since 9/11, they are both "closed base". If you have legitimate business on them (which I have had, via my street sweeper company on construction projects), I have still been able to metal detect them.

And the presidio is a little more complicated than year's past too: Starting about 15 years ago (or since 9/11?) the "lower" presidio is now a separate entity than the upper presidio. The "upper" presdio (everything beyond check-point charlie and the fences) is still the language school. While the "lower presidio" is leased to the city of Monterey for $1 p/year, for public access historical park. So it's a quasi-arrangement of city and fed. City is in charge of it, but land underneath is still federal. I know some guys who took advantage of the fact that it now "city" (or is it?) to help themselves there metal detecting (since the city has no specific "no detecting" policy). HOWEVER, go figure, it's a highly historic sensitive monument. Doh! And despite being city, I would not recommend it as a place to be a big sore thumb at. There's been reales and seateds, a nice bust half, cannon balls, buttons, etc.... found on the lower presidio. But I'm including finds from even as far back as the 1970s, when .... it was simply before the age of archaeological awareness, and ... no one cared.

There's even a cannon muzzle on display in the museum there. And though the dossier on it doesn't say, I know that it was found with a metal detector (d/t a friend of mine found it in the mid '70s, and donated it about 7 or 8 years ago). Also a cannon-ball soon to be on display there was also dug with a metal detector. I talked a friend of mine into donating that, since I docent there. When we handed it over to the curator, we even told them "found with a metal detector". But believe it or not, they had permission! And that was as recent as the early '90s! Long story, but it had to do with my friend was friends with a high ranking highly decorated soldier stationed there. So .... they merely helped themselves. And if anyone gave them any grief, the military guy just flashed his rank. I "guess" you'd call that "permission"? I dunno.

At the upper presidio it all post-dates 1902. I used to detect up there a lot when I was in my 20s and '30s. The usual wheaties, merc's, and lots of military buttons and stuff. But not the older caliber stuff of the lower presidio.
 
Well? Did you ever find anything? :?: :lol: Did you even get to swing the detector? Uptown, I blame YOU for this......:roll:

ha, well, metal detecting at Ft. Ord in many years before this, and many years after this, has never been a big deal. One of the reasons it never occurred to me I needed to "ask" before bringing my detector on that hike, was that that others routinely detected there.

Like: if you get into the hobby and join a club (say for instance). And at the club's show & tell time, others show "found at such & such park" or "found at such & such beach". Then ... you ... as a newbie, just assume it must be ok to detect there. :?: It wouldn't even cross your mind as a question. Or like the analogy of coming to the pond in central park, and seeing toy RC boats on the pond. One assumes it must be legal (you'd probably never even muse the point).

So too was/is it for Ft. Ord: During the 1970s (when I was a kid) it was an open base at times, or during a few years, you signed in at the visitor center when coming on to base. We had 2 sizable clubs in this area, and a dealer since the very early 1970s, so there were already a lot of detectors around here by the late 1970s. And Ft. Ord was just one of the many places people detected. Of course, I'm sure they had the "presence of mind" to not go during the middle of drills, etc.. :roll:

And one of the reasons this might have just been "normal", was that since Ft. Ord was basically a city within itself, we always had a few enlisted military who were into the hobby themselves. So when they'd show up at the club meeting with all the goodies they were finding around barracks and such, then they simply invite their new found civilian friends to join them.

Thus for these reasons, it was never even wondered "is it legal?". This was in the days before the internet and FMDAC mailers flooded us with "scary stories", afterall, which NOW causes every new person to scurry down to "ask permission". I suppose, that even back in the 1970s, if enough of us civilians had gone to enough military brass asking "can I?", well sure, maybe "no" would have been forthcoming. But SO TOO can the same thing be said of ANY city or county park, school, etc.... If you ask enough questions, with the right combination of words, you can ALWAYS fetch a "no".

Just answer the question please sir...........:lol:
 
Back
Top Bottom