I have the Garrett 5x8, Garrett 8.5x11, and the NEL Thunder 10.5x14.5. I switch between them regularly.
I found 11 silver coins on my property with the stock 8.5x11 coil before I bought the 5x8. The positive reviewers of the 5x8 claimed they returned to previously hunted areas and found handfuls of missed coins.
After buying the 5x8 coil I returned to areas of my property that I know are loaded with nails and foil. But, these are also walking traffic areas near the house and I'd found a few coins already. I assumed I would unmask some coins with the 5x8 and better separation. Indeed, I could evaluate the signals faster with the 5x8 than the 8.5x11, but I only found one additional coin after what felt like 100 holes and lots of old nails and tiny bits of junk. I could pat myself on the back and say I already did a good job working the 8.5x11 in a trashy area. I've also since learned to be more discriminating with the 5x8 and not dig everything that gives a tiny high tone blip.
Where I did unearth more coins with the 5x8 was in other areas near trees and other obstacles.
Based on my experience, if somebody is finding "handfuls" of coins with the 5x8 in areas they've previously hunted with the 8.5x11, then they were working too quickly, only working in one direction, or simply couldn't/didn't get the coil over the coin. They might have been able to hunt faster if they had the 5x8 first and then followed up with a larger coil.
The 5x8 has lots of strengths. I like it. It's much more maneuverable and much lighter than the stock coil. In some locations it is deep enough. I can assess a target with it faster. I can clear out lots of shallower targets without tiring out my shoulder. But, then I switch to a larger coil. That inch or two can make a difference, especially if I'm already a couple of inches above the soil due to ground ivy, pine needles, or thick grass.