Because it is fairly common (20 million minted) and also a dug coin, I personally would probably pay around $2-$3 for it, while someone else might pay more.
This is the "What's the Value" subsection, with a lot of well versed coin collectors, dealers and former dealers. Google can be misleading because most of the images and prices you see are for high grade examples. Those that don't know a lot about coins can get misleading info. This and other coin forums are a good place to start on what the true value of a coin is.