Another Fire Victim....I'm at Peace With It

AirmetTango

Forum Supporter
Joined
Apr 14, 2017
Messages
3,134
Location
NW Ohio
Some of you might remember that I found a fire damaged 1876 CC Seated Liberty dime at a permission a little over a week ago. I went out to the same permission today to sneak a hunt in between rain storms. I wasn't having much luck outside of trash - a couple old ceramic fuses (patent number was awarded in 1950), lots of tire valve stems, and a couple other doodads.

Thunder started rumbling in the near distance as I finished up the side yard, so I moved to a new spot a little closer to my car in case I needed to make a fast dash through a sudden downpour. Within a couple minutes, I got a diggable signal that turned out to be a neat old brass item...maybe a hair clip?

Then immediately after that, I got over a mostly solid 90 signal showing 6" down. I opened the plug, and at the 5" mark my pinpointer only just started to sound off. Hmmm...this might be big junk - it's deeper than expected. I got up and swept the hole again with the detector - still solid 90 one way, but turning 90 degrees brought a little hiccup to the tone, and I saw the VDI dip momentarily to 40s. "Well, I've gone this far, may as well see what it is", I thought. I dug down a little more, just past 6". The pinpointer was sounding off in a pretty large area at the bottom of the hole - this was looking even more like a "bigger than coin" target.

The thunder was closer now, and the rain started falling again - just one or two drops at first, but noticeably increasing in intensity with each passing second. I almost considered closing the hole and calling it a day - but figured "nah, it's the last hole - may as well finish". A couple more small scoops, and I suddenly saw something big, round, and dark pop and then quickly settle back to the bottom. I reached in to retrieve it and placed it on my dirt pile - at first I thought it was a medal of some kind, but then I noticed the reeding around the edge.

Suddenly, I knew this was dollar coin - but I could also tell right away I had another fire victim. Now that I know exactly what a fire damaged silver coin looks like, the evidence was immediately recognizable - a pebbled and warped surface, distinct staining. Despite all the damage, I was able to make out just enough vague detail to ID it as a Peace Dollar. The detail is actually a little easier to see in the dirty pics...the spikes of Liberty's crown, the shape of her head, and a "2" to likely nail it down as minted in "192?". On the back, you can barely make out the curve of the Eagle's breast, and some rays of the sunrise at the edge of the coin.

It would have been an awesome find - Peace Dollars are just such beautiful coins! It easily would have been one of my absolute favorite finds. Instead, it might just be one of my most disappointing :no: Still, it's big silver...and I can technically say I've found a Peace Dollar! So I've made my peace with the find :lol:
 

Attachments

  • B31A77ED-1874-4DDA-9D4C-015C16151C83.jpg
    B31A77ED-1874-4DDA-9D4C-015C16151C83.jpg
    123.5 KB · Views: 580
  • 83EEDF48-4678-4914-B3AE-DEBACAC179E8.jpg
    83EEDF48-4678-4914-B3AE-DEBACAC179E8.jpg
    67.9 KB · Views: 536
  • C0BE2046-E9BD-437A-BEDE-542A800933EE.jpg
    C0BE2046-E9BD-437A-BEDE-542A800933EE.jpg
    53.3 KB · Views: 530
  • 4A512009-24EC-43F4-B823-77507ACB9EB4.jpg
    4A512009-24EC-43F4-B823-77507ACB9EB4.jpg
    127.8 KB · Views: 544
  • FBA7AC57-07F2-425D-8D0C-692EF596E1EF.jpg
    FBA7AC57-07F2-425D-8D0C-692EF596E1EF.jpg
    163.4 KB · Views: 540
  • A413A049-AE0F-4A86-8B9D-08876E7D9140.jpg
    A413A049-AE0F-4A86-8B9D-08876E7D9140.jpg
    158.1 KB · Views: 560
  • C19C697D-3740-4D33-A00A-74565A4EF3B8.jpg
    C19C697D-3740-4D33-A00A-74565A4EF3B8.jpg
    139.8 KB · Views: 550
  • A1F487B0-E5E9-47DD-9877-2B475C946388.jpg
    A1F487B0-E5E9-47DD-9877-2B475C946388.jpg
    165.2 KB · Views: 551
  • 1494E405-D29F-4F2C-903E-43FFC3A9D8F0.jpg
    1494E405-D29F-4F2C-903E-43FFC3A9D8F0.jpg
    50 KB · Views: 539
  • 957BA20F-E222-4805-8538-3741F5EFA5F7.jpg
    957BA20F-E222-4805-8538-3741F5EFA5F7.jpg
    74.1 KB · Views: 545
Sweet find buddy. I would take a silver dollar any day of the week, burnt or mint.
 
That is definitely a big chunk of silver ! Congratulations on the silver dollar that is definitely a bucket lister for lots of people.

Great post and write up glad to see that you were able to make it out.:stormy:Looking forward to see what else you can pull out of there. KEEP YOUR COIL TO THE SOIL.
HH & GL
 
Sweet find buddy. I would take a silver dollar any day of the week, burnt or mint.

Thanks, Usa - yep, I'll take it! I'm glad I could at least get a positive ID on it!

Awesome!

Welcome to the silver dollar club!!!

Huge congrats!!

<°)))>{

Thanks, Ice! Despite the damage, it was pretty cool to realize what it was as I inspected it by the hole. She's seen better days, but she's my first silver dollar! And all these fire damaged coins from the site might start shedding light on some forgotten history on the property.

Nice big chunk of silver for the melt pile, premelted even!

:lol: Melt value is currently $11, so even in it's current state, it's the most valuable silver coin I've found!!

That is definitely a big chunk of silver ! Congratulations on the silver dollar that is definitely a bucket lister for lots of people.

Great post and write up glad to see that you were able to make it out.:stormy:Looking forward to see what else you can pull out of there.

Thanks, Dan! There's definitely a lot more to find there - I'm just starting to get a little worried that all the best coins are coming up fire damaged. This coin was on the opposite side of the property from where I found the fire damaged Seated dime.

Melted, pristine, or anything in between....silver is silver! Nice dig!

Thanks, GimmeAbeer - I agree. This one might be in rough shape, but it's got character and maybe a story to tell about the property. And it gets me into the silver dollar club regardless :yes: Sure beats coming home skunked!
 
Beautiful coin! Congrats on the seated and the Peace! I dream of both!

Nice work! Can’t wait to see what else you find there, I have a feeling a lot!
 
That silver dollar has a better fusion crust than most of the rocks people think are meteorites...lol...it's a shame she's toasty..but it's a nice conversation piece..
 
Now Thats a Fire! WTG AT! Ya figure theres more that went up in flames?

Congratulations on that Silver Dollar!...its a Beauty!

BTW..Great pics and hunt write up! AAA+++
 
I’d be happy with a silver anything, this year my best finds were a 64 rose a barber dime a silver ring and my favorite a platinum ring[emoji41]


Bounty hunter - treasure hunter - cabelas
Best find to date - 15g platinum ring
 
"I'm at Peace with it" :lol: That's clever...and perfect, considering your previous find and the realization that it was permanent fire damage.
Great write up. Sure glad you finished digging that target!
 
Back
Top Bottom