Should i trade???

[Riley M.]

Hello everyone i just won a 1961 franklin nickel, and my grandfather has offered to trade and give me a 1942 quarter, a 1909 old nickel made before the buff nickel, and ten wheaties. wut should i do???? should i trade?

[AIRFORCEMIKE]

I say you trade...cause your grandfather will love it and im sure at some point you will inherit that whole collection..a win/win for you!!!

[longbeard]

give it to him.whats wrong with you?

[RWJR13]

Thats what I say, give it to him....

[carcur]

whats a Franklin nickle?
or do you mean Jefferson

[Arisaka]

Originally Posted by longbeard

give it to him.whats wrong with you?

[Bigpoppa]

Originally Posted by carcur

whats a Franklin nickle?
or do you mean Jefferson

I was thinking the same thing..

Unless of course it is the only known example of a 1961 Franklin Nickel to exist and then I would say keep it...


Give it to Grandpops...He was making you an offer you couldn't refuse

[Perquimans]

Maybe you mean a 1961 Franklin half dollar? Give it to him

[KingTotsalot]

You would certainly please your grandpa if you gave it to him on a special occasion like his B-day or Christmas....make it a surprize and you will not believe how much he will appreciate such a thoughtful gesture! Relationships are much more valuable than any coin!

[Riley M.]

Originally Posted by longbeard

give it to him.whats wrong with you?

I traded, and i keep them in a keepsake box on my book shelf. That was a real good deal!